Friends of Big Bend National Park
Big Bend Conservancy

Over-estimating your experience or under-estimating the terrain in a place like Big Bend can result in serious injury or death. Use the information and advice found here wisely. Climb/Hike/Camp/Drive at your own risk.

+-Calendar for sale

 2019 BigBendChat Calendar on sale now!


No need to filter water in the backcountry... Because 'Slate' magazine says so

  • 9 Replies
  • 931 Views
*

Offline PyramidBlaster

  • Coyote
  • *
  • 224
  • 3AM Eternal...
This is how people die. Or wish they were dead, I guess...

https://slate.com/technology/2018/02/filtering-stream-water-or-fresh-water-is-medically-unnecessary.html

And, of course, there's already a rebuttal in Outside magazine:

https://www.outsideonline.com/2279401/actually-slate-you-really-should-filter-your-water

Sure. I get where they're coming from, but I bet the idiot who wrote this article didn't get a rabid case of Giardiasis thirty miles into the backcountry, without a cell signal. (Perhaps someone should correct this situation, to provide some much-needed perspective....) :banghead: :willynilly:
"The most merciful thing in the world, I think, is the inability of the human mind to correlate all its contents."-H.P. Lovecraft

*

Offline Jalco

  • Mountain Lion
  • *
  • 1051
An ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure...
Better safe than sorry...

*

Offline Homer Wilson

  • Black Bear
  • *
  • 562
I hike, have fun, and then have to go back to work.  I don't have time to recover from a waterborne illness.  My sawyer filter weighs nothing and cost $20.  That's a very low cost insurance policy. 

Also, in BB, we often can't, as the author put it, "choos[e] selectively among water sources and drinking from them directly".  Here's me filtering water in the Chisos.  Would this scummy pool be one of the select sources the author would drink from?  Most assuredly not.  But it was my only source.  (Ok there were some even scummier ponds)  So I filter.


I do think he probably has a point that #2 hygene may be where the camper can be most vulnerable to disease.

*

Offline elhombre

  • Golden Eagle
  • Mountain Lion
  • *
  • 1137
I would bet that if the "No-filter water" author watched the family of javalina roll around having a gay old time cooling and watering themselves in a spring in the Fresno drainage that we were blessed to watch, he would have a different opinion.  They chased and squealed after each other for 15 minutes.  I didn't see a one of them wash their feet before jumping in and rolling around in the mud/ water hole.

This "far whiter, wealthier, and better educated" backpacker will continue to treat my water.

What was the purpose of the article?  Was the author so much smarter than us that he had to write an article making fun of backpackers that filter water?  Or is it he's pissed off that he can't afford a "$99.95" filter and must impune us moron "whiter, wealthier, and better educated" backpackers?

I'm going to guess he thinks he's just that much more smarter.   :o
« Last Edit: February 07, 2018, 07:48:31 PM by elhombre »
For 2 years the Fake News Media, Obama's FBI, CIA & DOJ, and Swamp dwelling Politicians COLLUDED, Illegally Spied,and LIED to America about POTUS in order to overturn an election

All the while demanding censorship and removal of opposition Conservative "hate speech" voices.  Globalists Hate Freedom

*

Offline Al

  • Dog Face Moth
  • Mountain Lion
  • *
  • 4078
I especially appreciate having filtered the water when walking upstream afterwards to find an animal lying dead and rotting in the water.  I have a friend that drank unpurified water in New Mexico and got Giordia.  Not to be wished upon your worst enemy.

*

Offline dprather

  • Mountain Lion
  • *
  • 2411
I have seen dead critters in streams
Leave "quit" at the car.  Embrace the trail as your friend.  Expect to enjoy yourself, and to be amazed.

*

Offline House Made of Dawn

  • www.youtube.com/watch?v=h2YJduDyFA4
  • Golden Eagle
  • Mountain Lion
  • *
  • 2966
  • Backpacking since '78, Big Bend since '95.
I contracted giardiasis just once. Very, very, very unpleasant. I don't ever want to do that again. And I've gotten the garden-variety backcountry "squirts" many times (even once on my last cross-park attempt, but didn't figure ya'll wanted to hear about that). That's why I always include immodium in my kit.

On my very first backpacking trip up into the Chisos (during a general hantavirus scare in the southwest US) I was filtering water out of a steel tub near the corral when a dead rat floated up to surface. That was a bit unnerving. A few years later, I was backpacking in Carlsbad Caverns NP, counting on a steel cattle tank in the backcountry for the next day's water. When I approached the tank and looked over the rim, I found the forward remains of a dead cow in it (not sure how that came to be). Took a bit of willpower to filter water out of that one.

I think I'll stick with filters and pills and give a pass on the joys of unpurified water.
« Last Edit: February 07, 2018, 10:00:20 PM by House Made of Dawn »
"The trick, William Potter, is not minding that it hurts."

*

Offline nuggetf5

  • Golden Eagle
  • Coyote
  • *
  • 102
  • Currently hiking around Lawrence, KS
    • Mandolin Cafe
Ah, the Slate crowd. I sense decaf soy chai lattes, neck beards, flannel shirts, stocking caps (indoors only, thank you) and electric cars, with homes in places like San Francisco, Seattle, Portland, Austin (you didn't think you were getting off did you?), maybe Brooklyn (Greenpoint and Williamsburg only, please, no pretenders from Flatbush) all teetering on every word. But that's just the smart-ass in me.

This essay online I stole sort of sums up my thoughts. YMMV.

So why do I hate Slate so much?

I think it's the sense-- perceived or real--that all of these thought-provoking, well-written, and easily-digestible articles are authored by people my age or younger who all purport to have the wisdom of ten thousand Yodas, when their tender years render such wisdom a nullity. The sanctimony and all-around unctuous tone of the headlines say it all.


And to think, that added unnecessary pack weight--maybe 1/10 of an ounce-- of water purification tablets I take on my hikes in BB and elsewhere. Yea, think I'll keep carrying those.
« Last Edit: February 07, 2018, 09:56:47 PM by nuggetf5 »
Mandolin Cafe
Since 1995

*

Offline Quatro

  • Diamondback
  • *
  • 466
Seat belts.  Another waste of time and energy based on the odds.
When the going gets weird, the weird turn pro - HST

*

Offline House Made of Dawn

  • www.youtube.com/watch?v=h2YJduDyFA4
  • Golden Eagle
  • Mountain Lion
  • *
  • 2966
  • Backpacking since '78, Big Bend since '95.

I do think he probably has a point that #2 hygene may be where the camper can be most vulnerable to disease.


Yep. No argument there. One careless mistake can ruin a trip...or a month.
"The trick, William Potter, is not minding that it hurts."

 


©COPYRIGHT NOTICE

All photographs and content posted by members are to be considered copyrighted by their respective owners and may not be used for any purposes, commercial or otherwise, without permission.

+-Calendar For Sale

 2019 BigBendChat Calendar on sale now!

Powered by EzPortal

Facebook Comments